Syllogisms
A syllogism is a type of argument formed by using categorical sentences as
premises and a categorical proposition as conclusion. A syllogism has exactly
two premises. Exactly three terms occur in the three categorical sentences which
make up the syllogism. The subject term of the conclusion is called the minor
term. It must occur as the subject term of the conclusion and also in one of the
premises. The premise containing the subject term is called the minor premise.
The predicate term of the conclusion is called the major term. Besides occurring
in the conclusion, it occurs in one premise, called the major premise. The third
term, called the middle term, occurs in each of the premises. When a syllogism
is in the order:
major premise |
minor premise |
conclusion |
it is said t be in standard form.
Let's look at the following syllogism:
All bass are fish. |
<-- NOT IN STANDARD FORM |
All fish are swimmers. |
All bass are swimmers. |
major term: swimmers
minor term: bass
middle term: fish
major premises: All
fish are swimmers
minor premise: All bass are fish.
Notice that the syllogism above is not in standard form. To be in standard form the
major premise must be first. In standard form the above syllogism is:
All fish are swimmers. |
All bass are fish. |
All bass are swimmers. |
We can characterize standard form syllogisms completely by specifying their
mood and their figure. The mood of a standard form syllogism is an ordered
triple of the letter names of the major premise, minor premise, and conclusion,
in that order. The above syllogism has the mood AAA. The following standard form
syllogism:
Some dogs are happy |
Some dogs are not brown. |
No brown things are happy. |
has the mood: IOE.
The figure of a standard form syllogism is determined by the relative
position of the middle term in the premises. There are four different figures,
each with a number-name:
M |
P |
|
P |
M |
|
M |
P |
|
P |
M |
S |
M |
|
S |
M |
|
M |
S |
|
M |
S |
Figure 1 |
|
Figure 2 |
|
Figure 3 |
|
Figure 4 |
In our last syllogism (the "dog" syllogism) the figure is 3. Thus
we specify the mood and figure together as I)E?3. In our "fish"
syllogism, the figure was 1. Hence the mood and figure are AAA-1. Note
that mood and figure apply only to standard form syllogisms.