Wednesday, February 29, 2012 |
III. International
factor migration
B.
International investment (cont'd.)
? Hypothesis--comparing rich and poor countries, who should borrow and who should lend on balance?
Examples:
% of GDP: | Total Domestic Consumption (private+public) |
Private savings S |
Public savings (T-G) |
Total domestic
savings S+(T-G) |
I | NX=NFI | |
United States | 2007 | 86% | 16% | -2% | 14% | 19% | -5% |
2010 | 88% | 22% | -10% | 12% | 15% | -3% | |
China | 2004 | 54% | 48% | -2% | 46% | 43% | +3% |
Greece | 2007 | 88% | 19% | -7% | 12% | 26% | -14% |
2009 | 93% | 23% | -16% | 7% | 18% | -11% | |
Germany | 2009 | 79% | 24% | -2% | 22% | 17% | +5% |
Guatemala | 2009 | 96% | 7% | -3% | 4% | 13% | -9% |
Note: To join the EU, must budget deficit and current account deficit cannot exceed 3% of GDP
Result 1: NFI is determined by a country's (1)
savings rate and (2) domestic investment opportunities
Some poor countries have very high investment
but even higher savings rates--China
Some rich countries have low savings rates, such as the US
and Greece
Result 2:
Economic analysis => foreign investment returns are not a net drain on the
borrower country welfare
(vs. popular criticism of profit remission by
transnational corporations)
(1)
NFI: $ flow in (2) Interest and dividends => paying for use of foreign capital => $ flow back out In theory, the result should be a win-win situation.
|
![]() |
||||||||||||
IV. The overall results of globalization
Recall the
Image
contrasting North and South Korea:
But to say globalization beats isolation doesn't get us very
far--our goal then becomes how to make globalization work as well as possible
Globalization and the real
world
What kinds of complications can arise?
What does the evidence say?
Issues:
Efficiency: Growth
Equity: Income distribution
Conclusions from
trade models:
Efficiency: Globalizers increase
their national welfare
Equity: Not everyone gains, including
unskilled labor in MDCs
We have seen how
trade affects DC wages.
Consider trade and factor migration combined:
worksheet