Jim Whitney Economics 311

Wednesday, February 29, 2012

III. International factor migration
B. International investment (cont'd.)

    ? Hypothesis--comparing rich and poor countries, who should borrow and who should lend on balance?

Examples:

% of GDP:    Total Domestic Consumption (private+public) Private savings
S
Public savings
(T-G)
Total domestic savings
S+(T-G)
I NX=NFI
United States 2007 86% 16% -2% 14% 19% -5%
  2010 88% 22% -10% 12% 15% -3%
China 2004 54% 48% -2% 46% 43% +3%
Greece  2007 88% 19% -7% 12% 26% -14%
  2009 93% 23% -16% 7% 18% -11%
Germany 2009 79% 24% -2% 22% 17% +5%
Guatemala  2009 96% 7% -3% 4% 13% -9%

Note: To join the EU, must budget deficit and current account deficit cannot exceed 3% of GDP

Result 1: NFI is determined by a country's (1) savings rate and (2) domestic investment opportunities
    Some poor countries have very high investment but even higher savings rates--China
    Some rich countries have low savings rates, such as the US and Greece


 

Result 2: Economic analysis => foreign investment returns are not a net drain on the borrower country welfare
   
(vs. popular criticism of profit remission by transnational corporations)

    (1) NFI: $ flow in
    (2) Interest and dividends => paying for use of foreign capital => $ flow back out

In theory, the result should be a win-win situation.

+ foreign investment
--> + output and revenue
--> + profits for DC investors &
  + wages for LDC workers

 

   

 

IV. The overall results of globalization

    Recall the Image contrasting North and South Korea:
    But to say globalization beats isolation doesn't get us very far--our goal then becomes how to make globalization work as well as possible

    Globalization and the real world
    What kinds of complications can arise?
    What does the evidence say?

    Issues:
        Efficiency: Growth
        Equity: Income distribution

    Conclusions from trade models:
        Efficiency: Globalizers increase their national welfare
        Equity: Not everyone gains, including unskilled labor in MDCs

    We have seen how trade affects DC wages.
    Consider trade and factor migration combined: worksheet