Jim Whitney Economics 102
Comparing derivatives with slopes over a discrete range

Consider the following total cost (TC) function we've been using a lot this term:
    TC = 196 + 147Q - 24Q2 + 2Q3
where Q = 1000s of units and TC = $1000s.

    Using the old slope method over the usual big range: If we use the old slope method of calculating MC, we actually get the average MC of output over a discrete range:
In 1,000s In true units Estimated MC
Quantity Total cost Quantity Total cost
0 $196 0 $196,000   $321,000-$196,000   $125,000 
  ----------------- = -------- = $125 
    1,000 - 0           1,000
1 $321 1,000 $321,000
 
    Applying the old slope method to a smaller range: What we really want is a more precise estimate of the slope, to find the marginal cost of unit number 1000 itself. Continuing with the discrete method, and plugging in actual values, we would have:
In 1,000s 
(true units)
MC
Quantity Total cost
.999 
(999)
$320.89498 
($320,894.98)
$321,000-$320,894.98   $105.02 
-------------------- = ------- = $105.02 
  1,000 - 999             1
1 
(1,000)
$321 
($321,000)
 
    Using the derivative: The actual derivative is MC = dTC/dQ = 147 - 48Q + 6Q2. Simply plugging in Q=1 gives:
        MC at Q=1 = 105.
So notice it's a much more precise estimate of MC than the old slope method over a big range, and it gets even better as the units of measurement get larger.

Here's what it looks like: