Jim Whitney Economics 101

Free trade versus protection

Suppose the U.S. can produce steel itself and also buy or sell as much steel as it wants on the world market at a price of $400 per ton. The market is depicted in the supply and demand diagram to the right.

        A=64
        B=14
        C=2
        D=1
        E=10
        F=2
        G=4
        H=2
        I=1
        J=8

Pre-trade versus free trade (with free-trade price (Pf) = $400 per ton):
  Pre-trade Free trade Change
Price      
Quantity consumed      
Quantity produced      
Quantity imported      
Consumer surplus A = ABCDEFGHI =  
Producer surplus BEJ = J =  
National welfare ABEJ = ABCEDFGHIJ =  
 
Free trade versus protection (tariff = $200 per ton, raising domestic price to $600 per ton (Pt))
  Free trade Tariff Change
Price      
Quantity consumed      
Quantity produced      
Quantity imported      
Consumer surplus ABCDEFGHI = ABCD =  
Producer surplus J = EJ =   
Government revenue 0 GH =  
National welfare ABCDEFGHIJ = ABCDEJGH =