Translation, Validity and
Proof in PL
Solution, Question 7
I will find a job when I graduate only if I am well prepared, and I will be well prepared only if I can read and write extremely well and have a good technical education. I will read and write extremely well if and only if I take a lot of Humanities courses, but if I take a lot of Humanities courses, I will not take many technical courses, and if I don't take many technical courses, then I won't have a good technical education. Therefore, I won't find a job when I graduate.
A: I will find a job when I graduate.
B: I am well prepared
C: I can read extremely well.
D: I can write extremely well.
E: I have a good technical education.
F: I take a lot of Humanities courses.
G: I will take many technical courses.
Translation:
A ⊃ B
B ⊃ ((C & D) & E)
(C & D) ≡ F
F ⊃ ~G
~G ⊃ ~E
~A
The argument is invalid, so there is no proof.
Thanks to Serena Francisco for discovering an error in an earlier posting of this translation!