Solutions to Constructing proofs of arguments in QL

Proof 5

 

1. (x)(Mx ~Px) premise  
2. (x)(Sx Mx) premise  
3. flag a Flagging restriction for U.G. SP1
4. Ma ~Pa U.I., 1 SP1
5. Sa   Ma U.I. 2 SP1
6. Sa ~Pa H.S. 4, 5 SP1
7. (x)(Sx ~Px) U. G. 3-6